Fuel Station Pulse Survey Results: Self Service vs Full Service. Who is Winning the Customer Experience Race?

Are New Zealand’s fuel stations truly delivering for today’s customers?
Hoed Research’s nationwide audit, covering leading fuel brands,
reveals a clear winner in the battle between Self Service and Full-Service stations.

Where customers fuel and pay independently, often via mobile apps
or pay-at-pump systems, with no shop visit.

Where customers receive staff assistance, make a fuel purchase,
and complete a small transaction in the shop.

KEY TAKEAWAY

Customers are embracing the speed, convenience, and reliability of self-service options,
especially when paired with intuitive mobile apps and seamless payment experiences.

SURVEY HIGHLIGHTS

BP, Caltex, Challenge, GAS, GULL, Mobil, NPD, Waitomo,
representing a wide spectrum of New Zealand’s fuel retail landscape.


Self Service Stations

Strengths:
Mobile app experience, pump & payment process, overall service

Customer Satisfaction:
All respondents “Very Satisfied”; high Net Promoter Scores (8–10/10)

Areas to Improve:
Clearer signage at some locations, occasional app/payment glitches


Full Service Stations

Strengths:
Shop interior & atmosphere, efficient staff

Customer Satisfaction:
Most rated service as “Very Good” or “Good”

Areas to Improve:
More proactive staff engagement, upselling, and consistent payment experience

“Fast, clean, and easy, just how I like it.”
“Apps make payment a breeze. I’ll be back!”

“Staff were polite and efficient, but I’d love a more personal touch.”
“Shops are tidy and inviting, but some could engage customers more.”

RECOMMENDATIONS

Invest in clear signage and reliable app/payment systems
Ensure amenities (air, water, paper towel) are visible and accessible
Address technical issues promptly

Customer sentiment is overwhelmingly positive across both models, with strong intent to return and recommend. The future of fuel retail is convenience-driven, are you ready to deliver?